Upgrade or Clean Install?
 
  Tweaks.com
 Home    Members    Calendar    Who's On        Main Site
 




Upgrade or Clean Install?Expand / Collapse
Author
Message
Posted 11/19/2008 11:02 AM


Forum Administrator

Forum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum Administrator

Group: Administrators
Last Login: 8/9/2008 6:13 AM
Posts: 8,284, Visits: 16,485
I've purchased a new system that ships with Vista Premium 64bit installed. I am a Microsoft Partner and have a Vista Ultimate 64 bit disk, and intend to upgrade the new PC once it arrives. I've always been an advocate of clean installs as opposed to upgrades, but since this is nothing more than a version upgrade I'm wondering if there really is any reason not to do an in-place upgrade of the OS.

I'd appreciate hearing from anyone who has actually done an upgrade from one version of Vista to another to hear if there were any issues after the fact. Thanks very much in advance.


________________________________________


Post #245504
Posted 11/19/2008 1:40 PM


Forum Moderator

Forum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum Moderator

Group: Moderators
Last Login: 8/9/2008 9:55 AM
Posts: 2,250, Visits: 3,998
I am also in your situation but with Vista Business, not Home Basic or Home Premium.

I do have Vista Ultimate but the disks [both versions] came from the Consumer Preview Program [a Beta thing].

With Business I did the install [clean] but did not enter the CD Key then reinstalled over itself and entered the key, seems to be fine on 2 Desktops and one Notebook. The process has been commonly available on the 'net.
This is the page I used:
http://www.winsupersite.com/showcase/winvista_upgrade_clean.asp

I think that with Vista you could do the same, install Ultimate over Home Basic or Home Premium [can't go the other way]. It should be the same as upgrading WinXP Home Edition to WinXP Professional.


__________________________________________________

Post #245507
Posted 11/19/2008 5:06 PM


Forum Administrator

Forum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum Administrator

Group: Administrators
Last Login: 8/9/2008 6:13 AM
Posts: 8,284, Visits: 16,485
Berton (11/19/2008)
It should be the same as upgrading WinXP Home Edition to WinXP Professional.

That was exactly my thought. Thanks Berton.

________________________________________


Post #245510
Posted 11/19/2008 9:11 PM


Forum Moderator

Forum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum ModeratorForum Moderator

Group: Moderators
Last Login: 8/9/2008 9:55 AM
Posts: 2,250, Visits: 3,998
You're welcome, good luck.

__________________________________________________

Post #245514
Posted 11/20/2008 7:43 AM


Senior Forum Advisor

Senior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum Advisor

Group: Senior Advisor
Last Login: 8/8/2008 7:33 PM
Posts: 1,436, Visits: 775
I can confirm the install of Vista Business as a full install without the product key and then installing it again as the Upgrade I acutally purchased. HTH

________________________________________________________________

Post #245526
Posted 11/20/2008 8:06 AM


Forum Administrator

Forum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum Administrator

Group: Administrators
Last Login: 8/9/2008 6:13 AM
Posts: 8,284, Visits: 16,485
Thanks AD, but what I'm most interested in is hearing from someone who has actually done an in-place Vista version upgrade to find out if there is any performance difference between that and a clean install.

________________________________________


Post #245527
Posted 11/20/2008 7:02 PM


Senior Forum Advisor

Senior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum AdvisorSenior Forum Advisor

Group: Senior Advisor
Last Login: 8/8/2008 7:33 PM
Posts: 1,436, Visits: 775
Im sure you could. I don't have a spare system to try it on, but you could try to take a Vista DVD and do a clean install, use no product key and select a lower version for that clean install. then boot into windows and try to upgrade there. A virtual pc app could prob let you figure that out as well. Just ideas

________________________________________________________________

Post #245536
Posted 11/23/2008 7:27 AM


Forum Administrator

Forum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum AdministratorForum Administrator

Group: Administrators
Last Login: 8/9/2008 6:13 AM
Posts: 8,284, Visits: 16,485
I'm just assuming that I can use a FULL version of Ultimate 64 to do the upgrade, just as is the case with XP, and that I don't need an upgrade disk.

________________________________________


Post #245629